← Back to the Punchline

Worked case · Illustrative scenario

Investigate offsetting till variances

Till A is Rp500,000 short and Till B is Rp500,000 over. A zero store total does not explain either exception.

RecordAmount / quantity
Till A−Rp500,000
Till B+Rp500,000
Net store varianceRp0
Absolute differences requiring explanationRp1,000,000

1. Keep each till visible

Retain signed independent count sheets by till, cashier and shift. Compare physical cash to the expected balance before netting or adjustment.

2. Reconstruct the movements

Trace opening floats, sales, refunds, voids, cash drops and transfers. Compare timestamps, custody records and approvals. Check count and posting errors as well as unexplained differences.

3. Test the recurring pattern

Compare prior periods and identify whether the same tills, users or transfer process recur. Offset amounts are a signal to investigate, not proof of misconduct.

4. Close the cause separately

Record a supported explanation and authorised correction for each till. Assign unresolved differences and verify the corrective action in a later count.

Test your reasoning

Would a signed transfer of Rp500,000 settle both differences?

Compare your reasoning

Only if its direction, time, custody trail and posting reconcile both tills. A signature or equal amount alone is insufficient. Test whether the correction resolves each balance and whether the recurring cause has been addressed.

Keep learning

Follow the full discipline case →

Working tools to adapt

Inside Assurance Toolkit #08 — Audit Finding Working Paper →

Data Analytics Exception Review: Keep the Reasoning Behind the Result →

Original teaching example. Adapt tests to your evidence, systems and approval procedures.

Inside Assurance

Leave us a message.

We review messages and reply by email. Your text stays in this window until you send it.

Please avoid confidential company information or sensitive personal data.

Reply by email · No live chat
Search the full library