Inside the Punchline
Editorial cartoon / Risk & Controls

Financial Crime Case #3: The Model Worked Perfectly

A reviewer approves a US$1.5 million model gain while someone behind a wall turns the benchmark-price dial feeding the model.

Use Zoom in to read the details. Scroll across and down to explore; Escape closes this view.

What would you check first?

The valuation model reports a US$1.5 million gain. Who supplied the benchmark, and how independently was it checked?

Behind the Punchline

The question behind the cartoon

Trace each significant input to its original source. Check who could influence the benchmark, compare independent price evidence and test sensitivity to alternative inputs. A model matching its benchmark is not an independent check when both depend on the same controlled source.

Work through the issue

Illustrative scenario · Inside Assurance

Inside Assurance

Leave us a message.

We review messages and reply by email. Your text stays in this window until you send it.

Please avoid confidential company information or sensitive personal data.

Reply by email · No live chat
Search the full library