Inside the Punchline
Editorial cartoon / Inventory

The Stock Count Was Perfect

An auditor lifts a Rp100,000 book-cost tag to reveal a Rp45,000 clearance price while a manager displays a matched count sheet.

Use Zoom in to read the details. Scroll across and down to explore; Escape closes this view.

What would you check first?

The quantity matches, but stock booked at Rp100,000 is on clearance for Rp45,000. What would you check next?

Behind the Punchline

What a perfect stock count still cannot prove

The count matches, but stock recorded at Rp100,000 is offered for Rp45,000. Existence and recoverability need different evidence.

What evidence would you examine?

Inspect product condition, age, subsequent sales, clearance terms and expected selling costs. Establish whether Rp45,000 is representative and comparable to the recorded unit cost.

What could explain it?

A temporary promotion, damaged stock, obsolescence or a pricing decision can affect interpretation. A clearance sign alone does not establish the amount of a write-down.

What decision follows?

Refer supported valuation concerns to Finance for assessment under the applicable accounting policy. Keep quantity conclusions and valuation conclusions separate.

Work through the checks
  1. Separate quantity from valuation. A matched count confirms units observed; it does not establish what those units can recover.
  2. Check whether the clearance price is representative using subsequent sales, product condition and expected selling costs.
  3. Document the basis for the valuation review separately from the count sheets and send unresolved items to the responsible reviewer.
Explore the Accounting learning map

Illustrative scenario · Inside Assurance

Inside Assurance

Leave us a message.

We review messages and reply by email. Your text stays in this window until you send it.

Please avoid confidential company information or sensitive personal data.

Reply by email · No live chat
Search the full library